calvinism

How Does Calvinism Practically Teach a License to Sin?

How does Calvinism communicate that people have a license to sin?  The core tenets of Calvinism are often called “the doctrines of grace” by Calvinists.  The grace of God, as it is actually taught in the Bible, does not provide a license to sin.  Grace, as defined by Calvinism, does indeed teach that people have a license to sin.  How this is practically done is what will be analyzed here.  

Calvinists try to say that Calvinism does not teach a license to sin by claiming that a truly regenerate individual “hates sin and desires righteousness.”  This is one example of how even typical defenses which Calvinists make of their theology still demonstrate that Calvinism teaches a license to sin. 

One of Calvinism’s many problems is that it grossly underestimates the moral capabilities of unregenerate humanity.  This underestimation actually makes sin sound not nearly as evil as it is since it gives people who live in sin the false impression that they could not possibly do any better than they are doing.  Calvinism communicates that sinners cannot help being sinners due to how they are supposedly incapable of being otherwise since it teaches that no one can repent as they are required to unless God regenerates them beforehand.  As a result, it ultimately places the burden of man’s repentance upon God rather than upon sinners where it belongs according to the Bible and common sense.  The Bible certainly teaches that repentance comes before regeneration and not the other way around like Calvinism teaches (see Acts 2:38, Acts 11:18, etc).  This simple truth invalidates all of Calvinism since it strikes at the concept of Total Depravity, the chief cornerstone of the whole Calvinist system.  Saying that regenerate individuals hate sin and desire righteousness does not correct the lie which is at the very root of Calvinism.  The statement rather, when made in the context of Calvinism, communicates the lie that it is God’s job to regulate a person’s attitude towards sin.

Moreover, everyone has God’s law written on their heart and a conscience which is intact to some degree.  One can be an enemy of God who is committed to sin (and that is actually how the Bible defines a sinner) while still desiring righteousness and hating sin to a notable degree.  Just because a person is not surrendered to do what is right in God’s eyes does not mean that there are not some sins which they hate nor does it mean that they do not desire righteousness in many ways.  Saying that regenerate individuals hate sin and desire righteousness is too vague.  That description can be applied to unregenerate people as well.  That makes it at best a pointless statement on its own.  It could easily even make someone think they are right with the Lord when they are not.

Worse yet, Calvinism even misleads people about what it means to endure in faith in Christ through its twisted understanding of many things related to Christian victory.  It is normal to hear Calvinists teach that the new birth in Christ changes a person so that they automatically desire holiness over sin going forward.  They simultaneously teach that it is inevitable that new creatures in Christ will continually succumb to sin.  This is demonstrated by how Calvin, Luther, and Reformation theology teachers in general say that the carnal, wretched man sold under sin in Romans chapter 7 is the Apostle Paul as a faithful Christian.  

If you think that teaching some people hate sin and desire righteousness at heart while simultaneously teaching that the same must inevitably give into it anyways sounds like repackaged Gnosticism, you are right.  Gnosticism heavily influenced the leaders of the Reformation (Luther, Calvin, Zwingli, etc).  They were all heavily influenced by Augustine before they left the Catholic Church.  They also carried that influence with them (as well as many Catholic practices such as infant baptism) after they exited the Catholic Church.  

Since Calvinism teaches that born-again Christians inevitably succumb to sin continually, it practically teaches that continually practicing sin is acceptable, victorious Christianity in God’s eyes.  How can it teach otherwise when it claims that the experience of the wretched man in Romans 7 is a description of the Apostle Paul’s own experience as he wrote Romans?  Calvinist preachers can occasionally even make people feel guilty for simply being enticed by sin even when they don’t give into sin’s enticement.  Yet Calvinism also teaches that anyone who claims to be rejecting temptation and walking in victory over sin must be a liar.  Heeding this counsel obviously will make one believe that they have a license to practice sin.  

People might even interpret the guilt and self-loathing they experience as they wallow in sin as proof that their heart is right.  It is easy for one to use the discomfort they feel from the cries of their guilty conscience to tell themselves that they must really deep down “hate sin and desire righteousness.”  And if the cries of their guilty conscience should diminish as they wallow in sin, the Calvinist system even provides them with ammunition to interpret this as proof that they are trusting more deeply in the merits of Christ to justify them and thus obtaining a greater confidence in the grace of God.  This is also undeniable since Calvinism teaches that the wretched man in Romans 7 is Paul as a faithful Christian.  Calvinism also hereby provides its adherents ammunition to falsely accuse any faithful Christian whom they might meet of being a deceived liar should they honestly say they have practical victory over sin and deliverance from being a wretched sinner.  They also have ammunition to accuse those who say we need to have a living faith in Jesus which actually obeys Him of “not really trusting in Jesus” through Calvinism’s demonic imputed righteousness of Christ and faith alone doctrines which they have erroneously received as sound Biblical doctrine.  

Moreover, Calvinism provides its adherents ammunition to tell others that they are going to hell for committing the very same sins which they commit.  It inevitably leads to this double standard and extreme presumption by teaching that the elect can never possibly end up in hell no matter what they do.  It teaches that these will be irresistibly compelled to repent before they die no matter what horrid things they do while everyone else could never even possibly come to repentance ever.  Calvinism also provides its adherents an open door to carelessly tell a fellow Calvinist who is sinning in a way that really bothers them, or who maybe they just don’t like, that they were never even really born-again to begin with.  This happens while they also tell other people who are living like devils that they are justified by faith alone and do not need to worry about going to hell for the wretched deeds they are committing.  This is the kind of delusional, hypocritical stuff that believing in Calvinism actually leads people to.

Though Calvinists argue that true regeneration changes a person’s desires and produces ongoing faith and repentance while persistent unrepentant sin is evidence that someone was never truly regenerated, in saying this they are essentially making the claim that regeneration is a fix-all event which guarantees ultimate victory.  This is not the case.  Believing that it is the case diminishes large portions of Biblical counsel and discounts many realities which the Bible sets forth.  It does not teach that victory is guaranteed for someone just because they have been regenerated.  There is free will after regeneration as well beforehand.  It is possible for someone to die spiritually after really being born-again.  Someone is extremely likely, if not altogether certain, to take their ease and sin carelessly when they believe that their new birth in itself guarantees them ultimate victory in the end.  That is like a person who must fight countless heated battles in a deadly war thinking that they cannot possibly be killed because they have been provided armor and weapons.  Besides these things, Calvinists saying that persistent unrepentant sin is evidence that someone was never truly regenerated is either just damage control or an absolute joke anyways.  They also believe that the carnal wretched man who continually succumbs to sin in Romans chapter 7 is the regenerated Apostle Paul himself at the time he wrote Romans.  

Though Paul was not actually describing his present state in describing the carnal wretched man in Romans chapter 7, it is still possible that this wretched man’s experience could correspond to a person’s experience after undergoing a new birth in Christ.  Yet this is not acceptable and this is not Christian victory.  The reality that it happens is rather proof that the new birth does not in itself provide a person with victory in Christ.  It is also not a guarantee that the one who experienced it will persevere in repentance and faith in Christ.  One must indeed become a new creature in Him in order to really have power over sin through the Holy Spirit.  Yet this victory is still difficult and not guaranteed to happen after one is born-again.  

It is especially easy for an authentic Christian to fail to go forward on the narrow way to life and eventually die spiritually if they believe that the carnal wretched man in Romans 7 is actually a faithful, victorious Christian like Calvinism teaches.  In holding this belief they are given a justification to not suffer in order to actually deny themselves the pleasure of sin and live under the authority of Christ so that they walk straight on the narrow way.  And as one believes they are justified by faith alone in accordance with what Calvinism and Reformed theology in general teach, they must also believe that their salvation is not dependent upon them actually living in victory over sin and doing what is pleasing in God’s eyes.  This is utterly contrary to what the Bible teaches.

James 1:12-15: “Blessed is the man that endureth temptation: for when he is tried, he shall receive the crown of life, which the Lord hath promised to them that love him.  Let no man say when he is tempted, I am tempted of God: for God cannot be tempted with evil, neither tempteth he any man: But every man is tempted, when he is drawn away of his own lust, and enticed.  Then when lust hath conceived, it bringeth forth sin: and sin, when it is finished, bringeth forth death.”

The preceding verses acknowledge that real born-again Christians are enticed by sin.  They also teach that acting upon sin’s enticement still leads to spiritual death for them.  Those who walk in sin are on a course of death whether they were ever really born-again before or not.  To think that sinning will not lead to death for someone because they might have a vague “hatred of sin and desire for righteousness” within them is extremely delusional.

What often happens is that people who obey the Gospel as God commands know that their life was really changed so that they do not have any reasonable doubt that they were made a new creature in Christ.  They begin well on the narrow way to life.  They then get ensnared by Calvinism afterwards.  Maybe they had already started to slip back into sin and they found Calvinism appealing as a result.  Or maybe they just heard a sermon from or read the book of a Calvinist which they didn’t have the discernment to see the errors in.  Now they believe that practicing wicked deeds could not possibly send them to hell since they now believe that God will make sure to bring them to repentance before they die no matter how much they turn aside from the narrow way.  Through the influence of Calvinism they assume “It is totally God’s job to preserve me” as they become careless with sin and live according to the dictates of their flesh.  Their heart hardens and their ears become dull to Biblical reproof.  Though some might say that such a person was never really regenerated, that is an unbiblical assumption and it is altogether unwarranted in several cases.  God does not irresistibly compel the unruly believer to return to their first love like the Calvinist preachers said would happen.  Unless the unruly one rejects the lies of Calvinism and really becomes diligent to turn around and get back on the right way, they will become very secure in their sin.  As this happens, they become two-fold the child of hell.  Maybe they will be welcomed among a lukewarm church.  Perhaps they will eventually forsake their Christian profession altogether while saying that Christianity didn’t work (when it was really Calvinism, which they wrongly equated with Biblical Christianity, that didn’t work).  

A true believer in Christ must be diligent to continue in faith by continuing in subjection to God’s Word.  Those who are not diligent will not walk in victory despite their previous new birth.  They will eventually fall away altogether if they do not repent and take the necessary Biblical measures to walk forward on the narrow way which they had previously begun on.  It is not entirely up to God to ensure that they are kept.  Calvinism presumptuously teaches that a truly regenerated person can never possibly fall away from Christ unto damnation at all.  The Bible teaches otherwise.     

Hebrews 3:12-15: “Take heed, brethren, lest there be in any of you an evil heart of unbelief, in departing from the living God.  But exhort one another daily, while it is called To day; lest any of you be hardened through the deceitfulness of sin.  For we are made partakers of Christ, if we hold the beginning of our confidence steadfast unto the end; While it is said, To day if ye will hear his voice, harden not your hearts, as in the provocation (this is referring to the generation of Israelites who disobeyed God in the wilderness and never entered the Promised Land as a result).”

The born-again Christian is in a war which they will not be victorious in unless they are very diligent and endure the suffering which is necessary to be faithful to the Lord.

Revelation 12:11: “And they overcame him (i.e. the devil) by the blood of the Lamb, and by the word of their testimony; and they loved not their lives unto the death.”

James 1:22: “But be ye doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving your own selves.”

It is no wonder that Martin Luther disdained the Book of James.  The Bible teaches against the faith alone concept while also not teaching salvation through the Catholic Church.  

James 2:14-17: “What doth it profit, my brethren, though a man say he hath faith, and have not works? can faith save him?  If a brother or sister be naked, and destitute of daily food, And one of you say unto them, Depart in peace, be ye warmed and filled; notwithstanding ye give them not those things which are needful to the body; what doth it profit?  Even so faith, if it hath not works, is dead, being alone.”

One must actually do what the Lord requires in order to really exercise faith in Him.  Works of this nature are indeed essential.  These do not purchase justification with God, yet they are absolutely necessary to comply with His terms for being justified through the blood of Christ.  Faith without these is dead.  A dead faith is obviously unprofitable.  Exercising saving faith in Christ is not something which can be done once so that it never needs to be done afterwards.  Contrary to Calvinism and Reformation theology, the born-again Christian can stall or turn aside from the narrow way to life and never recover.  

James 5:19-20: “Brethren, if any of you do err from the truth, and one convert him; Let him know, that he which converteth the sinner from the error of his way shall save a soul from death, and shall hide a multitude of sins.”

Calvinism teaches that if you are one of those whom God supposedly elected unconditionally to salvation before the world was made, then it is impossible for you to do anything that would cause Him to put you in hell.  And if you were not unconditionally elected, then Christ didn’t even die for you so there is nothing that you could ever possibly do to obtain His grace.  You are either guaranteed to be saved no matter how much you provoke God right now or you are guaranteed to burn in hell with absolutely no recourse.  Calvinism thus practically tells everyone that they might as well sin in every way they please and it will make no difference in the end.  It is a doctrine of demons which should be fled from.

Aaron’s email is: gospeltruth768@yahoo.com

CLICK HERE TO READ MULTIPLE STUDIES RE: CALVINISM

USE THE SEAERCH BUTTON ABOVE TO SEARCH FOR LONGER STUDIES ON THIS & OTHER SUBJECTS

CLICK HERE TO GO TO OUR FRONT PAGE FOR ALL THE STUDIES

CLICK HERE TO GO TO OUR 3RD WORLD MISSION TO THE IMPOVERISHED